Article: MacBook Repair vs. Replacement — A Cost Comparison (US vs. China)

Introduction

When your MacBook starts showing signs of trouble — whether it’s a failing battery, a broken screen, or a logic board issue — you’re faced with a crucial question: Should you repair it or replace it?
The answer often depends on where you are. The cost of Apple repairs varies dramatically between countries, particularly between the United States and China, where labor, parts pricing, and warranty policies differ significantly.

This article provides a clear cost comparison to help you make an informed decision.

1. MacBook Repair Costs in the United States

In the US, Apple Authorized Service Providers and Apple Stores follow standardized repair pricing.

• Battery replacement: around $199–$249 (depending on model)

• Screen replacement: $400–$700+

• Logic board replacement: $700–$1,000+

• Keyboard replacement (out of warranty): around $180–$350

If you own AppleCare+, some repairs (like battery or accidental damage) may cost much less — usually $99–$299 per incident.

Independent repair shops can offer lower rates — often 30–50% cheaper — but using unofficial parts might void your warranty.

2. MacBook Repair Costs in China

In China, MacBook repair prices are generally lower, due to reduced labor costs and the widespread availability of third-party parts.

• Battery replacement: around ¥800–¥1,200 (≈$110–$160)

• Screen replacement: ¥2,000–¥3,500 (≈$270–$480)

• Logic board replacement: ¥4,000–¥6,000 (≈$550–$830)

• Keyboard replacement: ¥600–¥1,000 (≈$80–$140)

Authorized Apple repairs in China tend to mirror US prices, but independent service centers are much more common and often more affordable. However, customers must be careful to choose reputable providers to ensure quality parts and workmanship.

3. When to Repair vs. Replace

Here’s a practical breakdown:

General rule:

• If your repair costs exceed 50% of the cost of a new MacBook, replacement is more economical.

• If your MacBook is less than 3 years old, repair is often worth it — especially in China.

4. Factors to Consider

1. Warranty and AppleCare+: Check your coverage before deciding.

2. Performance Needs: Newer MacBooks have vastly improved chips (like M2/M3).

3. Data Security: Repairs require backups — consider privacy and data handling.

4. Sustainability: Repairing is often more eco-friendly.

5. Final Verdict

• In the US: Repairs are reliable but expensive; replacing may make sense for older devices.

• In China: Repairs are more affordable, making it a better option to extend your MacBook’s life.

Bottom line:
If your MacBook’s issue is minor or under three years old, repair it — especially in China.
If it’s major, out of warranty, or over five years old, replacement is the smarter long-term move.